localnews.ie

Ifeyinwa and Joseph Gorry immigration case goes to Supreme Court on Minister's appeal

By Donal Gilhooly

Historic decision · Decision date:

The Court said High Court and Court of Appeal decisions on foreign spouses of Irish citizens have been inconsistent, and the Gorrys had opposed leave.

The Supreme Court has granted the Minister for Justice and Equality leave to appeal a Court of Appeal decision in the case of Ifeyinwa Gorry and Joseph Gorry, in a determination delivered on 11 April 2018. The Gorrys had opposed the application.

The Court of Appeal ruled on 27 October 2017, in judgments from Finlay Geoghegan J. and Hogan J. The Minister's application was technically out of time when delivered on 2 January 2018 and was filed on 9 January 2018, but the Gorrys did not oppose an extension and the Court extended time.

The dispute is over an immigration decision that refused permission for the non-national spouse of an Irish citizen to remain in or enter the State. The High Court (Mac Eochaidh J.) quashed the Minister's decision on 6 February 2014. The Court of Appeal agreed that the Minister had not considered the couple's constitutional rights in accordance with law.

That court held that an Irish citizen has no automatic constitutional right to live with a non-national spouse in Ireland. It found that a lawfully married couple still have rights protected by Article 41, and that the Minister must have due regard to them. It also held that the "insurmountable obstacles" test from the European Court of Human Rights still applies under Article 8.

The Minister argues that the Court of Appeal misapplied Supreme Court case law on how these rights are weighed. The Minister also says its approach to the Cirpaci decision is inconsistent with earlier authority.

The Supreme Court noted that High Court decisions on the issue have been inconsistent, and that the Court of Appeal took significantly different views in different cases. It said the issue "requires to be clarified".

The Gorrys say their appeal is moot because they have lived apart for three years. The Court noted the issue, and will list the case for case management with Ford, ABM and Hussain, where one or possibly two appeals would be heard first.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal