The Supreme Court will hear an appeal by the Minister for Justice and Equality in an immigration case brought by Alison Ford and David Nwoke, it decided on 11 April 2018. The Court said the Court of Appeal's decision rested on the reasoning in another case, Gorry, where leave to appeal had already been granted.
Ms Ford and Mr Nwoke had opposed the application. The Minister filed on 9 January 2018, which was technically out of time. The extension was not opposed and the Court extended time.
The case was one of three appeals heard together in the Court of Appeal, which gave separate judgments on 27 October 2017. The others were Gorry and ABM. The Minister has applied for leave in each.
Each involves an Irish citizen married to a foreign national. In each, judicial review was sought of an immigration decision by the Minister that refused or prevented the non-national spouse from remaining in, or entering, the State. In this case the High Court (Eager J.) quashed the Minister's decision on 19 November 2015.
The Court of Appeal found the decision wrongly applied the same principles to the Article 41 constitutional rights of the spouses as to their rights under Article 8 of the European Convention on Human Rights. It upheld the order quashing the decision. It said the appeal was moot because Mr Nwoke had made further applications, and so vacated the part of the order sending the matter back to the Minister.
The Supreme Court said the appeal was moot by then, but the legal principles are the same as in Gorry, ABM and a fourth case, Hussain. All four will be listed for case management.
It said one or possibly two would be heard first, with the others waiting for the result. Case management will decide which proceeds.