The Supreme Court has agreed to hear an appeal by the Director of Public Prosecutions, the Commissioner of An Garda Síochána and the Minister for Justice and Equality in cases brought by Gavin Owens and Patrick Dooley over unpaid fines, it decided on 10 April 2018. Mr Owens and Mr Dooley did not oppose the application for leave.
The two cases were dealt with in a single Court of Appeal judgment, Owens and Dooley v The Director of Public Prosecutions and others [2017] IECA 299, delivered on 16 November 2017. The order was perfected on 4 January 2018, and the State parties applied for leave on 26 January 2018, within time.
The issue in both cases is whether unpaid fines imposed as part of a sentence before the Fines (Payments and Recovery) Act 2014 came into force should, after that date, be dealt with under that Act or under the law as it stood at the time of sentence. Each man was the subject of a committal warrant issued under the older system.
Mr Owens and Mr Dooley each obtained an order from the High Court quashing the warrant, in a judgment cited as Dooley and Owens v The Director of Public Prosecutions and others [2017] IEHC 271. The State parties' appeal to the Court of Appeal was unsuccessful, except in respect of one element of the High Court order.
Mr Owens and Mr Dooley do not oppose leave, though they deny the merits of the State's arguments on the substantive issue. The Supreme Court said it was satisfied the issue is one of general public importance and granted leave to appeal.