The Supreme Court refused Michael Murray leave to appeal against a Court of Appeal decision that increased his prison sentence, in a determination delivered on 10 April 2018.
After a contested trial, the Central Criminal Court sentenced Mr Murray to a total of 15 years on counts including rape, aggravated sexual assault, false imprisonment, threatening to kill and abduction of the complainant's child. The Court of Appeal found the sentences "inadequate to a significant extent" and so unduly lenient. It substituted 19 years in a judgment of 3 November 2017. Mr Murray applied for leave on 4 January 2018, within time.
His main argument was that 15 years sat within the range of 15 years to life identified for the most serious category of rape offences, so there was no error in principle.
The Supreme Court did not accept that the application met the constitutional requirements of general public importance or the interests of justice. It said a sentence within a range can still be an error in principle if it does not reflect the circumstances of the case. It noted the Court of Appeal had considered the effect on the victim, his criminal record, the aggravating factors and the absence of mitigating factors.
Mr Murray also argued that the lack of established sentencing tariffs is unfair. The Court said it may have to consider that in an appropriate case, but saw no benefit to him in granting leave for that purpose.