The Supreme Court refused Maureen Arnold and Dan Arnold leave to appeal against a Court of Appeal decision that upheld the refusal of leave to seek judicial review of their convictions for failing to comply with a school attendance notice, in a determination delivered on 9 April 2018.
Judge Aeneas McCarthy of Fermoy District Court convicted each parent on 10 April 2015 under section 25(1) of the Education (Welfare) Act 2000. The High Court (Binchy J.) refused them leave to seek judicial review on 22 January 2016, and the Court of Appeal dismissed their appeals in a judgment of 27 November 2017.
They applied for leave to appeal on 2 January 2018. The Court of Appeal had held that they had shown no arguable grounds on any of the five issues raised, and had found no arguable case on their new challenge to the constitutionality of the 2000 Act because they offered no evidence that their daughter was receiving a minimum standard of education.
The Supreme Court accepted that the interpretation of the 2000 Act is a matter of general public importance. It said applicants must also show some prospect of success, and that these applicants had not, having seemingly misunderstood the offence: they were convicted of failing to comply with the notice, not of failing to send their daughter to school.
It held that the Court of Appeal's analysis of each ground was correct and refused leave.