Vyautas Dunauskis, whose surrender is sought by Germany to face trial for murder, has been granted leave to appeal to the Supreme Court in a determination delivered on 15 March 2018. The Minister for Justice and Equality opposed the application.
The request comes from the Federal Republic of Germany under a European Arrest Warrant dated 13 May 2016. The High Court (Donnelly J.) ordered Mr Dunauskis's surrender under the European Arrest Warrant Act 2003, as amended.
The central issue was whether the public prosecutor who issued the warrant, the Chief Public Prosecutor in Lubeck, is a judicial authority within the meaning of the Act. The High Court relied on a presumption that the issuing authority is valid and applied a test that the prosecuting authority must be independent of the executive and participate in the administration of justice. It held that Mr Dunauskis had not rebutted the presumption.
The High Court certified questions of law on that test, and Mr Dunauskis appealed to the Court of Appeal. In a judgment delivered by Birmingham J. on 20 October 2017, with Mahon and Hedigan JJ. concurring, the Court of Appeal answered all the questions in the affirmative. It dismissed the appeal by an order of 3 November 2017.
Mr Dunauskis applied for leave on 13 November 2017, and the application was in time. He argued that the correct test is a question affecting every Irish arrest warrant case where the issuing authority is challenged. The Minister did not dispute that the test applies in all such cases.
The Supreme Court decided that the test for whether a prosecuting authority is a valid issuing judicial authority is a matter of general public importance. Leave was granted on the grounds in his application, which may be the subject of directions at case management stage. The Court said it will consider the most expeditious way to decide both appeals together.