The Supreme Court refused Hany Boles leave to appeal a Court of Appeal costs order in his personal injury case against ABP Ireland, trading as ABP Cahir, on 9 March 2018. The decision means the order stands.
Mr Boles argued it was unfair that no order was made for his costs of the appeal, after he defeated the company's appeal on liability and part of its appeal on damages. He said he may have to meet those costs from his award.
He was injured in an accident at work on 25 May 2007. The High Court (O'Neill J.) found the company liable and awarded him €257,000.
The Court of Appeal dismissed the company's appeal on liability and rejected its claim that the loss of earnings award was excessive. It cut the general damages by €30,000, to €60,000. It noted that the company had made a Calderbank offer of €200,000 between the two hearings, and made no order as to the costs of the appeal.
The Supreme Court said the decision was a matter of discretion on the particular facts, so no issue of general public importance arose. It said that arguing a decision is wrong does not meet the interests of justice test.
Leave to appeal was refused.