The Supreme Court has granted Mark Rickard leave to appeal a Court of Appeal decision in the case taken against him and Gerard Rickard by ACC Loan Management Limited. The determination was delivered on 6 February 2018. It means the Supreme Court will hear the appeal.
Mr Rickard, the first named defendant, applied for leave on 8 November 2017, and the application was in time. ACC Loan Management opposed it.
The case concerns a receiver by way of equitable execution, a court-appointed receiver who collects money to meet a judgment debt. On 4 October 2011 the High Court (Kelly J.) ordered a receiver over payments due to Mr Rickard from the Department of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food under the Single Payment Scheme. Between that date and 22 June 2015, €525,877.40 was received under that scheme.
When the Single Payment Scheme was replaced by the Basic Payment Scheme, ACC Loan Management applied to extend the order. On 13 July 2015 the High Court (McGovern J.) varied the order to cover Basic Payment Scheme payments.
Mr Rickard appealed to the Court of Appeal, arguing that a receiver cannot be appointed over assets held by way of a legal interest and that future, salary-like payments were out of reach. The Court of Appeal dismissed his appeal in a judgment of 31 July 2017, and its order was made on 11 October 2017.
ACC Loan Management argued the issue was a narrow private matter. The Supreme Court disagreed. It said the extent of a receiver's power over both equitable and legal interests is a matter of general public importance that goes beyond this case, partly because the Court of Appeal had reversed earlier authority.
The Court also said the appeal raises whether Basic Payment Scheme payments are in the nature of a salary. The appeal has not yet been decided.