John Allen has been refused leave to appeal to the Supreme Court in his bid to withdraw a notice of discontinuance of his claim against the State, in a determination delivered on 5 February 2018. The Court did not accept that the case met the constitutional threshold for an appeal.
Mr Allen issued personal injury proceedings in December 2003 over abuse he suffered as a pupil at a primary school run by Christian Brothers. The defendants included the Minister for Education and Science, the Attorney General and representatives of the school's board of management.
After the Supreme Court decided Louise O'Keeffe's case against the State, he discontinued his claim against the State defendants, serving notice on 2 June 2010. The European Court of Human Rights later ruled in Ms O'Keeffe's favour, on 28 January 2014, and Mr Allen then asked to set aside or withdraw the notice.
The High Court refused that application, and the Court of Appeal dismissed his appeal on 21 July 2017. He applied for leave on 23 August 2017, arguing that many people are affected and that he had been denied a domestic remedy.
The Supreme Court said the number of people affected does not make a decision one of general public importance. It said the Court of Appeal applied well established principles on discontinuance, and that Mr Allen had freely chosen to discontinue with legal advice.