The Supreme Court refused Mr Carney leave to appeal directly from the High Court in a dispute over an injunction affecting property in Cork city, on 2 February 2018. The case is listed as Costello v Carney.
He wanted to challenge a High Court order of 13 March 2017. That order affirmed an injunction granted by the Circuit Court, Cork Circuit, restraining him from entering the property. The injunction arose from default on mortgage repayments. His application for leave was made on 7 April 2017 and was in time.
His central argument was that the Circuit Court had no jurisdiction because the property has no rateable valuation. He relied on the Court of Appeal decision in Permanent TSB plc v Langan [2016] IECA 229.
The Supreme Court said that question had since been decided by the Supreme Court in Permanent TSB plc v Langan [2017] IESC 71. It held that a property without a rateable valuation does not exclude the Circuit Court's jurisdiction. The issue therefore fell away.
The Court also noted section 39 of the Courts of Justice Act 1936, which says High Court decisions on appeals from the Circuit Court are final and not appealable. It said whether that bars a direct appeal did not need to be decided here.
The Court refused leave to appeal.