localnews.ie

Supreme Court to hear Royal College of Surgeons appeal in Park West Clinic case

By Donal Gilhooly

Historic decision · Decision date:

The college sought to challenge how a central fact was determined by the Court of Appeal, in a judicial review where discovery had been ordered.

The Supreme Court has agreed to hear an appeal by the Royal College of Surgeons in Ireland in its case with RAS Medical Limited, trading as Park West Clinic. It made the decision in a determination delivered on 2 February 2018, and the clinic company had opposed leave.

The Court of Appeal gave judgment in the case on 31 July 2017, and its order was made on 5 October 2017. The college applied for leave to appeal on 8 November 2017, and the application was in time.

The college wants to raise how a central fact of particular importance to the case was determined in the courts below, and in particular by the Court of Appeal. The Supreme Court accepted that questions about findings of fact will rarely justify an appeal, because the governing principles are well settled.

It found this case different, because it is a judicial review in which discovery was ordered. Most judicial review proceedings are decided entirely on affidavit, and discovered documents cannot be admitted in evidence unless the parties agree or, in plenary proceedings, a witness is called to prove them. Parties sometimes agree to admit such documents as prima facie proof of their contents, on what is known as the Bula/Fyffes basis, and the Court said courts have repeatedly stressed the need for clarity about the basis of admission.

The Court was satisfied that the way certain discovered documents came before the courts below, were considered by them and formed part of the judgment raises an issue of general public importance. It said the appeal would bring further clarity to how discovered documents can be used, particularly in proceedings likely to be heard on affidavit.

Leave was granted on the grounds set out in the college's notice of application. The Court added that the case management judge may refine or adjust those grounds so the broad issue it identified can properly be addressed.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal