The Supreme Court refused Denis O'Brien leave to appeal a Court of Appeal decision in his case against Red Flag Consulting Limited, on 2 February 2018.
Mr O'Brien was the plaintiff and applicant. The defendants were Red Flag Consulting Limited, Karl Brophy, Seamus Conboy, Gavin O'Reilly, Brid Murphy and Kevin Hiney.
He wanted to appeal the Court of Appeal's judgment of 13 October 2017. The application for leave was made on 20 November 2017 and was in time.
The Supreme Court said the Court of Appeal had applied well established principles on relevance and necessity in discovery. It said the same about the rules on disclosing the identity of a potential wrongdoer.
It also said the Court of Appeal had identified the correct test from an earlier High Court case, Hartside Limited v Heineken Ireland Limited. On qualified privilege and honest opinion, it agreed the lower courts' decision turned on the particular wording of the category sought.
The Court was not satisfied the constitutional threshold for an appeal was met. It added that arguing a lower court was wrong is not enough on its own.