localnews.ie

Victoria Osinuga child benefit case: Minister for Social Protection granted Supreme Court appeal

By Rory Hanlon

Historic decision · Decision date:

The State will challenge a Court of Appeal declaration that denying child benefit to an Irish citizen child because of the mother's immigration status is unconstitutional.

The Supreme Court has granted the Minister for Social Protection, Ireland and the Attorney General leave to appeal in the Osinuga child benefit case. The determination was delivered on 21 December 2018. The respondents to the application, Victoria Osinuga and her mother Faith Osagie, opposed it.

The State applied on 26 September 2018 to appeal a Court of Appeal judgment of 5 June 2018.

Victoria Osinuga was born in Ireland on 23 December 2014. Her father is an Irish citizen, so she has been a citizen since birth. Her mother, Ms Osagie, was an asylum seeker at the time and was awaiting a decision on her application for permission to remain. They lived in direct provision. Ms Osagie applied for child benefit on 16 October 2015 and was refused because she had no right to reside. She was given permission to remain on 6 January 2016 and received child benefit after that. She took judicial review proceedings on 7 December 2015, seeking payment from the date of her daughter's birth.

Hogan J. gave the Court of Appeal judgment. He found that excluding a citizen from a universal payment because of the adult claimant's immigration status needed a high level of justification, and that none had been shown. The court declared that sections 246(6) and (7) of the Social Welfare Consolidation Act 2005 are incompatible with the Constitution so far as they prevent child benefit being paid for an Irish citizen child solely because of the parent's immigration status. The effect was suspended until February 2019.

The State argued that the Court of Appeal treated child benefit as the child's entitlement although it is paid to an adult. It said that could affect other welfare payments, and that the declaration could strike down both subsections, with consequences for payments relying on habitual residence.

Ms Osagie and her daughter said the case is not of general public importance and would affect fewer than a dozen litigants. If leave was granted, they wanted to defend the result on EU law and human rights grounds.

The Supreme Court said how child benefit is characterised could have important consequences beyond this case, and granted leave. The respondents may argue their additional grounds.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal