The Supreme Court has granted the Minister for Social Protection, Ireland and the Attorney General leave to appeal in the Agha child benefit case. The determination was delivered on 21 December 2018. The Agha family, who brought the case, opposed the application.
The State applied on 26 September 2018 to appeal a Court of Appeal judgment of 5 June 2018. The Irish Human Rights and Equality Commission is a notice party. The determination should be read with the Osinuga case, which raises a related question: whether there is an entitlement to child benefit before the qualifying parent has permission to remain in the State.
Daniel Agha was born in the State in 2013 to Afghan parents. The Refugee Appeals Tribunal declared him a refugee on 9 December 2014. His parents and three older siblings had also applied for asylum, and they applied instead for family reunification. While that decision was pending, his mother, Shazia Agha, applied for child benefit for all the children on 19 February 2015. It was refused on the basis that she was not habitually resident in the State while awaiting a decision. The family received permission to remain on 11 September 2015, and child benefit was paid after that.
Hogan J. gave the Court of Appeal judgment. He distinguished this case from Osinuga because Victoria Osinuga was a citizen with an unqualified right to reside. The court did not accept that the 1951 UN Refugee Convention had become part of EU law, but it read Article 28 of the EU Qualification Directive as requiring social assistance from the date international protection status is granted. Child benefit was therefore payable for Daniel from January 2015, and for his siblings only from September 2015.
The State disputes the description of child benefit as the child's entitlement, and disputes how Article 28 was applied to a parent without a right to reside. The family wish to argue that the relevant section of the Social Welfare Consolidation Act 2005 is incompatible with the European Convention on Human Rights, a point raised in the High Court.
The Supreme Court said the case raises an issue of general public importance and granted leave on the grounds in the State's notice. The family may make submissions on the Convention point.