The Supreme Court has granted Gavin Tobin leave to appeal in his case against the Minister for Defence, Ireland and the Attorney General. The determination was delivered on 17 December 2018. The State opposed the application.
Mr Tobin applied on 10 October 2018 to appeal a Court of Appeal judgment of 9 July 2018. That court had narrowed the scope of the discovery ordered by the High Court. Discovery is the process by which a party has to disclose documents in civil litigation.
The Supreme Court began by saying that orders for discovery are commonplace. It said ordinary issues arising from them could not meet the constitutional threshold, because applying well-established principles to the facts of a case is a matter for the High Court and, potentially, the Court of Appeal.
It also accepted some merit in the State's criticism that Mr Tobin's application concentrated too much on the merits of his appeal and did little to show the constitutional threshold was met.
The court said the real question was whether anything new or general in the Court of Appeal's approach to discovery warranted an appeal. In his judgment, Hogan J., speaking for the Court of Appeal, indicated there was something seriously amiss with the discovery system as it now operates and that courts should look for alternative solutions.
The Supreme Court was persuaded that this raised an issue of general public importance. It said the full breadth of discovery traditionally ordered may be disproportionate in modern conditions, and that there is a question about the precise way a court can or should limit its scope. It noted there has not been a definitive Supreme Court determination on the point in recent times.
Leave was granted on the basis set out in the application. The case management judge will decide whether the grounds come within the issue identified.