Pat Carty has been refused leave to appeal directly from the High Court to the Supreme Court over an order committing him for contempt. The Supreme Court delivered its determination on 30 November 2018.
Mr Carty is the defendant in proceedings brought by David Van Dessel. He applied on 13 November 2018 to appeal a High Court order made on 12 November 2018. Mr Van Dessel opposed the application.
Mr Carty argued that the original order made by Gilligan J., which he was found to have breached, took a different view of the law from that adopted by McDermott J. in what he said was a similar case. The finding of contempt and the committal followed from a ruling by Allen J.
The Supreme Court noted that Mr Carty has never appealed the original order of Gilligan J. It said a party must obey a court order while it stands, and must seek to have it changed by appeal or otherwise if they think it is wrong. It said there was some doubt whether the issue he wished to raise arose in an appeal against the committal order, but it did not need to decide that.
The court said it is no longer the Supreme Court's constitutional function simply to correct alleged errors in judgments. If there were inconsistencies between High Court judgments, the proper course was an ordinary appeal to the Court of Appeal. It found no exceptional circumstances justifying a direct appeal.