The Supreme Court has granted Dunnes Stores leave to appeal in its case against Paul McCann, Stephen Tennant and Point Village Developments Limited. The determination was delivered on 28 November 2018.
Dunnes applied on 11 September 2018 to appeal a Court of Appeal judgment of 23 July 2018, with the order made on 24 July 2018. The respondents opposed the application.
The case concerns an attempt to have a court decide a preliminary issue of law in a dispute that the parties had agreed in writing to refer to an expert for determination. The Supreme Court noted there is no Irish case directly on point, although there is a substantial body of United Kingdom authority. Dunnes relied on two UK decisions, Mercury Communication v Director General of Telecommunications and Barclays Bank v Nylon Capitol. Point Village argued that those cases were different, since they dealt with the scope of an expert's mandate or a condition precedent, rather than an expert having to resolve a contested question of law within an undisputed mandate.
The court said that how far a court can be asked in advance to decide questions of law in a dispute referred to an expert is of general importance, since parties often use expert determination. It was not satisfied the common law in Ireland matches that in the UK, or that the UK position is clear enough to remove doubt.
The Supreme Court also found a second ground. Dunnes said the Court of Appeal dismissed the proceedings although all it had been asked for was a stay, and that dismissal never arose at the hearing. Point Village said the stay sought would have stopped the case ever going ahead. The court said it was in the interests of justice to consider whether the dismissal was appropriate in an appeal against a stay application.
Leave was granted on all grounds, but the case management judge will make sure they fall within the basis identified.