The Supreme Court has granted Jacqueline McGovern leave to appeal in a property possession case brought by Seniors Money Mortgages (Ireland) Limited. The determination was delivered on 13 November 2018. The court will hear the appeal as a matter of urgency.
Ms McGovern, the daughter of the late Noelle McGovern, applied on 6 July 2018. She is appealing a Court of Appeal order of 25 June 2018 that refused her an extension of time to appeal a High Court order of 26 January 2017.
The case began as special summons proceedings seeking possession of a property in Co. Leitrim. The company claimed that Noelle McGovern, the owner, who died on 19 November 2000, had given it a mortgage deed dated 14 September 2007. Ms McGovern, who lives in the property with her husband, opposed the claim as a litigant in person. Baker J. in the High Court granted the order for possession. Ms McGovern was later substituted as defendant in her capacity as executrix of her mother's estate.
The Court of Appeal refused her application in three concurring ex tempore judgments from McGovern, Hogan and Irvine JJ. All three found she had not shown a genuine intention to appeal within the time allowed, or a mistake that might justify the delay. Two of the judges considered she had an arguable ground of appeal.
Seniors Money Mortgages opposed the application and said the Court of Appeal had applied well-established principles correctly.
The Supreme Court said the case raised a matter of general public importance. That is what the Court of Appeal should weigh when deciding whether to extend time to appeal, where an applicant has an arguable ground but has not shown an intention to appeal in time or a mistake that would justify the delay.
Because the appeal concerns a refusal to extend time, the court directed that a notice of intention to proceed be delivered within ten days of the determination.