Ciarán Mac Airt has been refused leave to appeal directly to the Supreme Court in his challenge to the appointment of Mr Harris as Garda Commissioner. The Supreme Court delivered its determination on 13 November 2018. The respondents were the Minister for Justice and Equality, Ireland and the Attorney General.
Mr Mac Airt applied on 7 September 2018 to appeal a High Court ruling of 22 August 2018. In that ex tempore ruling, McDonald J. refused him leave to bring judicial review proceedings. Mr Mac Airt argued that Mr Harris was not an appropriate person for the role because he had previously served as Deputy Chief Constable of the Police Service of Northern Ireland and, before that, in the Royal Ulster Constabulary. He claimed this would compromise him in investigating certain murders in Northern Ireland.
The High Court found he had not shown an arguable case. It said the application ignored the statutory appointment process, under which the Government must accept a nomination by the Policing Authority and can reject it only in exceptional circumstances.
The Supreme Court accepted the concerns relate to a matter of public importance. It said an appeal must first be stateable and that Mr Mac Airt had not addressed the statutory framework or set out a specific legal point. The Policing Authority's nomination had not been challenged. It said the trial judge had applied well-established case law.