The Supreme Court has granted Eilish Hardiman leave to appeal in a case brought against her by Leo Green over an operation in December 2007. The determination was delivered on 26 October 2018. Mr Green opposed the application.
Ms Hardiman applied on 31 July 2018 to appeal a Court of Appeal decision of 2 July 2018. The Court of Appeal (Finlay Geoghegan, Peart and Hogan JJ.) had dismissed her appeal from the High Court (Cross J.), which found that Mr Green's action was not statute-barred, meaning it had been brought in time.
The case centres on surgery Mr Green underwent on 11 December 2007 to repair a colovesical fistula. His small bowel was accidentally perforated during the operation, and a second operation followed on 19 December 2007. He was critically ill for a number of days and needed further hospital admissions up to 13 February 2008. Proceedings issued on 7 August 2012.
The courts accepted that if a CT scan had been carried out on 14 or 15 December 2007, Mr Green would probably not have endured the problems that followed. The High Court held that time began to run when he received his medical records on 31 March 2011. The Court of Appeal held it ran from the receipt of an expert report on 20 May 2012, so he did not have the necessary knowledge until then.
The Supreme Court said there was a concern that this was inconsistent with an earlier Court of Appeal decision in Farrell v Ryan. It noted questions over whether the date of knowledge should be measured from his consultation with a gastrointestinal surgeon, his consultation with a solicitor, his receipt of the records or the expert report.
It found the issue to be one of general public importance, requiring clarity on how section 2 of the Statute of Limitations (Amendment) Act 1991 applies.