The Supreme Court on 24 October 2018 granted John James Mungovan leave to appeal against a Court of Appeal decision in his case against Clare County Council. The court will hear the appeal on the question of whether his claim was brought out of time.
Mr Mungovan began the proceedings in 2011. He sought a declaration that a register of independent, suitably qualified agents and consultants for waste water treatment, which the council operated, was ultra vires and had no legal or statutory basis. He also sought damages for financial loss from his exclusion from the register, and damages for malicious falsehood.
The council argued that the case could not be maintained. It relied on section 50 of the Planning and Development Act 2000, which requires challenges to planning authority decisions to be brought by judicial review within eight weeks. It also relied on Order 84, Rule 21 of the Rules of the Superior Courts, which requires an application to be made promptly and within three months of the grounds first arising.
The High Court (Keane J.) held on 17 August 2015 that the claim was caught by both provisions. On 13 December 2017, the Court of Appeal held that section 50 did not apply, because the register was introduced before the 2006 amendment came into force. It upheld the High Court on Order 84, Rule 21, finding that the proceedings were not commenced promptly or within three months.
Mr Mungovan applied for leave on 30 May 2018, in time. He argued that his case was a claim in tort for malicious falsehood. He also argued that his complaint concerned the existence of a statutory register, which was still in place when he began proceedings, and not a decision of the planning authority.
The Supreme Court said the appeal involves important issues of law on the interpretation of statutory provisions and the application of the Rules of the Superior Courts. It said the approach to dismissing plenary proceedings for missing a time limit that applies to judicial review raises issues of general importance.
The court was not satisfied that the grounds in his application identified the central issues precisely, and it noted that the council may seek to raise further matters. The leave is therefore subject to refinement at case management.
For now, the appeal will proceed on one ground: that the Court of Appeal erred in upholding the finding that the claim was barred by Order 84, Rule 21, applied by analogy.