localnews.ie

Michael Sweeney right to silence case goes to Supreme Court on State appeal

By Ruairí Dolan

Historic decision · Decision date:

Ireland, the Attorney General and the Director of Public Prosecutions won leave to appeal directly from a High Court declaration against an Offences Against the State provision.

The Supreme Court on 24 October 2018 granted Ireland, the Attorney General and the Director of Public Prosecutions leave to appeal directly from the High Court in the case brought by Michael Sweeney. The court will now hear the State's appeal.

The High Court (Baker J.) ruled on 23 November 2017 that section 9(1)(b) of the Offences Against the State (Amendment) Act 1988 was repugnant to the Constitution. It found that the provision offended the constitutional right to silence and was impermissibly vague and uncertain.

The State parties first lodged an appeal with the Court of Appeal and mentioned it before that court. The Court of Appeal observed that the matter was quintessentially one for a direct appeal to the Supreme Court under Article 34.5.4 of the Constitution.

They then applied to the Supreme Court for leave to appeal, and for an extension of time. Mr Sweeney did not oppose either the extension or the application for leave.

The Supreme Court said this was an appropriate case for a direct appeal. It found that there was no factual controversy and that the case was a matter of legal argument alone.

It considered it unlikely that the issues would be significantly reduced or clarified by a full hearing in the Court of Appeal.

The court also pointed to the effect of the High Court decision, which invalidated a piece of legislation. While an appeal is pending, uncertainty will exist about the legislation itself and about the implications of the decision for other offences.

For that reason, it said, a final resolution of the issue is desirable. Leave was granted on the grounds set out in paragraph 6 of the State parties' application, subject to any clarification at case management.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal