The Supreme Court on 23 October 2018 granted the Minister for Public Expenditure and Reform leave to appeal in the public contract case brought by Word Perfect Translation Services Limited. The court will hear the appeal.
The case concerns a tender for translation services for public bodies generally. Such a contract involves considerable State expenditure.
The winning tenderer could expect a supply of work and profits.
The Court of Appeal decided the substance of the case on 7 June 2018. It required the tender process to start again.
The process involved several tenderers, most relevantly Word Perfect and a firm called Translations.ie. The Court of Appeal's order made the tender process void.
Word Perfect is the disappointed tenderer. Translations.ie is the firm apparently awarded the contract.
The case arises under the European Communities (Public Authorities' Contracts) (Review Procedures) Regulations 2010. Under them, a tender decision can be overturned only where a manifest error is shown.
In the High Court, Barrett J refused to overturn the award on 4 May 2018. He accepted that a narrative statement had been supplied.
He also found that the marks on professional development did not affect the final scores enough to upset the result.
The Court of Appeal took a different view on both points. It would not treat the tender documentation as a narrative.
It also held that the marks for keeping up language skills were a manifest error. Each point led it to overturn the award.
The Minister had earlier sought leave to appeal on an interlocutory basis. That application was refused.
The Minister applied again on 25 July 2018, after the Court of Appeal's final decision. The application was in time.
The Supreme Court said the application for leave was difficult to understand. It read both judgments itself and considered the overall justice of the case.
It decided that the constitutional criteria for a further appeal were met. It said the case raises issues of general public importance on public procurement.
The question is what test a court should apply in reviewing a tender award under the legislation. The court will also ask whether that test was met on the two grounds that led to the award being overturned.
Those grounds may be refined at a case conference before the appeal is heard.