localnews.ie

University College Cork granted Supreme Court leave to appeal in ESB flooding case

By Cathal Brosnan

Historic decision · Decision date:

The Supreme Court said the case raises new points of law on the liability of a dam operator, and also granted the Electricity Supply Board leave to appeal.

The Supreme Court on 17 October 2018 granted University College Cork leave to appeal in its flooding case against the Electricity Supply Board, finding that the case raises novel issues of law of general public importance. The court will now hear the appeal.

The case arises from flooding on the night of 19 and 20 November 2009. The ESB operates a hydro electric generating system on the River Lee, and released more than 500 m3/s that night, which was greatly in excess of the capacity of the river banks downstream.

After a trial of 104 days, the High Court found that the ESB had been negligent. It also held that UCC was 40% contributorily negligent. The Court of Appeal reversed the decision on the ESB's liability on 20 March 2018.

The Court of Appeal also held that, had it upheld the High Court on liability, it would have set aside the finding of contributory negligence. UCC applied for leave to appeal to the Supreme Court on 15 May 2018, and that application was in time.

The ESB opposed UCC's application. It lodged its own application to appeal the Court of Appeal's decision on contributory negligence, to operate only if UCC was given leave.

That application was made on 29 May 2018 and was out of time. The Supreme Court said it followed that the ESB's application must also be granted, as UCC accepted, and extended the time for it.

The court noted that the damage UCC suffered was extensive but was only one of almost 400 proceedings started against the ESB over the incident. The ESB operates 16 Category A dams within the State.

The issues include the liability of a dam operator to people or property downstream, the law on the existence and definition of a duty of care, and the liability of statutory undertakings generally and in nuisance.

Leave was granted to both parties on the grounds set out in their applications. The court said those grounds may be refined at case management.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal