localnews.ie

Michael Taylor refused Supreme Court appeal over Paul Kelly murder conviction in Clontarf

By Fionn Kelly

Historic decision · Decision date:

The Supreme Court said the trial judge's refusal to direct a not guilty verdict applied a well-established test, and that no reassessment of it was justified.

The Supreme Court on 12 October 2018 refused Michael Taylor leave to appeal against his conviction for the murder of Paul Kelly. Mr Taylor was convicted by a majority jury verdict in the Central Criminal Court on 14 November 2011 after a fifteen-day trial,.

Mr Kelly was found dead inside the door of his apartment building at Winstonville Apartments, Charlemont Road, Clontarf, Dublin 3, on 6 April 2007. The prosecution case was circumstantial and included DNA found on a glove.

At the close of the prosecution case, the trial judge refused to direct a verdict of not guilty. The Court of Appeal (Ryan P., Birmingham and Edwards JJ.) dismissed his appeal on 16 March 2018. It described the case as finely balanced and borderline, but held that the judge was entitled to leave it to the jury.

Mr Taylor sought leave to appeal only on that point. He asked the Supreme Court to depart from its own endorsement of the Galbraith test, arguing that any doubt in borderline cases should go to the accused.

The Supreme Court said the Galbraith principles have been adopted on very many occasions, including by that court, and are routinely applied. It saw no justification for reassessing them. It said the case applied an established test to particular facts, and no point of general public importance arose.

It also saw no obvious error of law in how the DNA evidence, which showed more than one person's profile, was handled.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal