localnews.ie

Thomas Kennedy and others refused Supreme Court appeal in tuna driftnet compensation case

By Fionn Kelly

Historic decision · Decision date:

The Supreme Court said the case turns on findings of fact that must first go to the Court of Appeal, and refused a direct appeal from the High Court.

The Supreme Court on 10 October 2018 refused Thomas Kennedy and other plaintiffs leave to appeal directly from the High Court in their case against the Minister for Agriculture, Fisheries and Food, the Minister for Finance, Ireland and the Attorney General. The plaintiffs also include Michael Murphy, Michael Hennessy, O'Mathuna (Baid) Teoranta, Vincent Browne, John O'Donnell, Paul Flannery, John Graham, Kieran O'Driscoll, Donal Healy, Neil Minihane, Gerard Minihane and Peter Carlton.

The appeal was sought from a High Court judgment delivered by Binchy J. on 21 July 2017, after a 17-day hearing. The application for leave was made on 23 January 2018 and was out of time.

The Supreme Court said two questions were central: when the cause of action accrued, and whether the plaintiffs had a legitimate expectation of compensation after the introduction of the European Union regulation prohibiting fishing for tuna with driftnets. The High Court made factual findings against the plaintiffs on both, and found that some of their evidence was self-contradictory.

Correcting findings of fact is not a function of the Supreme Court, it said. It added that a direct appeal based on such adverse findings would not be appropriate, because the case must first be dealt with by the Court of Appeal.

The court held that no sustainable case of general public importance had been established, and that the interests of justice did not require an appeal. As the application did not meet the threshold, it did not consider an extension of time.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal