localnews.ie

Gary Howard refused Supreme Court appeal over double murder conviction

By Cathal Brosnan

Historic decision · Decision date:

He was convicted of killing Paddy Mooney and Brendan Molyneaux at Pearce House, Dublin, and applied outside the time limit for leave to appeal.

The Supreme Court on 28 September 2018 refused Gary Howard leave to appeal his conviction for the murders of Paddy Mooney and Brendan Molyneaux. The two men were killed by gunshots on 10 January 2010 at Pearce House in Dublin.

A jury at the Central Criminal Court found Mr Howard guilty on two charges of murder. The Court of Appeal dismissed his appeal in a judgment delivered by Edwards J on 20 July 2016.

The order was perfected only on 7 February 2018, and Mr Howard applied for leave on 8 May 2018. That was out of time, and the Supreme Court declined to extend the deadline.

The application centred on whether his confession statement should have been admitted at trial and whether his detention was validly extended. He had been questioned at Kevin Street Garda Station.

The Court of Appeal had found that a request to see his solicitor was not passed on, through error. It also found that he had received comprehensive legal advice.

The Supreme Court said it is not a court for the correction of error, and that the case turned on its own facts. It added that recent rulings had dealt with the law on access to solicitors.

It declined to wait for another case before the European Court of Human Rights, and found the constitutional criteria had not been met.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal