The Supreme Court on 24 September 2018 refused Patrick McMahon and Angela McMahon leave to appeal in a case brought against them by Bank of Ireland.
They had asked to appeal directly from the High Court. Its decision of 15 June 2018 was made on an appeal from the Circuit Court.
The Supreme Court said it is unresolved whether an appeal lies from the High Court in such a case. It first asked whether the case would meet the constitutional threshold anyway.
It said the Supreme Court is no longer a court designed to correct error. Complaints about the lower courts' assessment of evidence could not be pursued.
The McMahons argued that their property rights and European law on unfair contract terms had been given too little regard. The court said the High Court judge had considered European law in detail.
They also complained of facing two sets of proceedings. The court said possession claims must be brought in the Circuit Court, which cannot deal with money claims over €75,000.
No notice had been given to the Attorney General for any claim that a law was invalid, and it was too late to raise it.
The court found that the constitutional threshold would not be met in any event, and refused leave.