The Supreme Court on 18 September 2018 refused Patrick Joseph Mangan leave to appeal against an order for his surrender to Spain on a European Arrest Warrant. Spain wants him for prosecution on one charge of alleged illicit trafficking of narcotic drugs and psychotropic substances on 29 November 2010. The maximum sentence he could face if convicted is six years and nine months.
It is alleged that Mr Mangan headed an organisation trafficking cannabis from Morocco to Spain. The evidence comes from intercepted calls between him, using an Irish phone in Ireland, and Anthony Joseph O'Neill, using a Spanish phone in Spain. The Spanish authorities had authorised interception of Mr O'Neill's phone.
The High Court (Donnelly J) ordered his surrender on 13 March 2017, after rejecting his claim that the wire-taps violated his privacy rights. The Court of Appeal (Birmingham, Mahon and Edwards JJ) dismissed his appeal on 11 December 2017. It held that Irish constitutional rights do not apply to a lawful interception in Spain.
Mr Mangan told the Supreme Court that the case raised cross-border interference with electronic communications. He also argued that the Court of Appeal had dealt with a case he had not made. The Minister for Justice and Equality opposed the application.
The Supreme Court found the premise of his application flawed, because both courts had found that the interception happened only in Spain. It saw no general public importance and no injustice, and refused leave to appeal.