The Supreme Court on 16 August 2018 refused Diarmuid MacConville leave to appeal a Court of Appeal decision. The case is Ciaran Tracey against Ireland, the Attorney General and the Referendum Returning Officer.
Mr Tracey had applied to the High Court for leave to present a referendum petition. He later withdrew that application on agreed terms as to costs.
Mr MacConville then sought to be substituted for him. The President of the High Court ruled that substitution was not possible after the proceedings had been struck out.
The Court of Appeal upheld those rulings in a judgment delivered by Irvine J. on 31 July 2018. It also made a costs order against Mr MacConville.
He applied to the Supreme Court on 7 August 2018. He relied on section 50 of the Referendum Act 1994, which he said set no time limit for substitution.
The Supreme Court called his first two arguments misconceived. It said there was no petition in being, only an application for leave to present one.
It found his reading of section 50 was wrong. The substitution procedure does not apply to an undetermined application for leave that the intended petitioner withdraws.
It said the costs order raised no issue of general public importance. His claim that the leave requirement is unconstitutional was not argued in the lower courts.
The court held that the application did not meet the constitutional criteria, and refused leave to appeal.