localnews.ie

Michael and Valerie Kelly refused Supreme Court appeal over Bank of Ireland Mortgage Bank sale order

By Orla Quinn

Historic decision · Decision date:

The couple sought a direct appeal from the High Court, which had allowed the bank to sell a mortgaged property they own with their daughter.

The Supreme Court refused Michael and Valerie Kelly leave to appeal on 1 August 2018. They had asked to bring a direct appeal from the High Court in a case taken by Bank of Ireland Mortgage Bank.

The Supreme Court said it was "well within the discretion of the Court" to make that order.

The High Court, on 2 May 2018, had affirmed a Circuit Court order. It allowed the bank to use the power of sale in a mortgage over a property owned by the Kellys and their daughter, Veronica Kelly.

The couple argued they were no longer in arrears. The High Court accepted that. But the full debt had been called in since 2 December 2014.

Veronica Kelly was in a personal insolvency arrangement that relied on selling the property. The High Court judge took that into account.

The Supreme Court said the Kellys had not shown exceptional circumstances to justify skipping the Court of Appeal. It also found no matter of general public importance or interests of justice issue.

Their application was also out of time. The court said the reasons they gave for extending time did not meet the legal test.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal