localnews.ie

Andrzej Gruchacz granted Supreme Court appeal over Athlone murder conviction

By Orla Quinn

Historic decision · Decision date:

The Supreme Court will hear arguments on how a jury identified him from CCTV footage and on the treatment of a witness as hostile.

The Supreme Court granted Andrzej Gruchacz leave to appeal on 30 July 2018 against his murder conviction. It will hear an appeal against the Court of Appeal judgment of 30 January 2018.

Mr Gruchacz and Leszek Sychulec were convicted on 22 April 2016 of the murder and false imprisonment of Patryk Krupa in Athlone. The offence took place on 20 June 2014. Mr Gruchacz was sentenced to life imprisonment. The Court of Appeal upheld his conviction.

Two issues arise. The first concerns CCTV footage and stills taken from it. A significant part of the evidence against Mr Gruchacz related to them. The jury was allowed to identify him from the images by comparing them with him in court.

Mr Gruchacz said this was not notified to him before the trial. He said it was a significant departure from the case law, and that the law on CCTV evidence needs clarification. The Director of Public Prosecutions relied on the view of the Court of Appeal that the jury was entitled to make that comparison.

The second issue concerns Tomasz Jaromin, a witness. The trial judge allowed him to be treated as hostile under section 16 of the Criminal Justice Act 2006, because he stood over most of his garda statement but not the identification. Mr Gruchacz said the law on this is unclear and that the witness was too readily treated as hostile. The Court of Appeal found the trial judge had ruled correctly.

The Supreme Court said both issues are ones "raised with reasonable frequency at criminal trials". It said there is a lack of recent legal authority and guidance. It held that they raise matters of general public importance.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal