The Supreme Court refused Cathal McCrudden, trading as McCruddens Filling Station, leave to appeal on 30 July 2018. He had asked to appeal directly from the High Court. The other side in the case is Fate Park Limited, trading as Finn Valley Oil.
Mr McCrudden wanted to challenge a High Court ruling by Barrett J. on 11 July 2017. The judge refused him more time to appeal an order of the Circuit Court. Fate Park opposed his application.
The Supreme Court said the High Court had applied long-established principles on extending time to appeal. It said there was nothing new or novel about the issues. It found no point of general public importance and no reason, in the interests of justice, to revisit the decision.
The Court said it is no longer a court concerned with correcting errors, even if there is one.
It also noted that Mr McCrudden's papers did not comply with its practice direction. He was written to and given a final chance to file more. He did not, and the Court decided the matter on the papers it had.