The Supreme Court refused Teresa and Michael Enright leave to appeal on 27 July 2018. They had asked to appeal directly from the High Court in a planning dispute with Wicklow County Council.
The council brought proceedings in the Circuit Court in County Wicklow over structures on land that was originally a public road. The road had been replaced by the new N11 at Arklow. The council said the structures were unauthorised development. Sean Whelan, the first respondent, has since died.
The Enrights argued that the council had ceded the land to them in a compromise of an earlier dispute. They said the structures were exempted development and that the case was statute barred. The Circuit Court rejected those arguments and the High Court did the same on appeal.
The High Court heard oral evidence and made findings of fact against the Enrights. It found that a gate was unauthorised development and that the evidence did not show the gate or a shed was in place before 13 June 2005. It also found commercial vehicles and materials on the land were used for a waste business.
The Supreme Court said the case stands on its own facts and raises no issue of general public importance. It said an appeal could not change the findings of fact. The application was also out of time, which was a reason in itself to refuse leave.