localnews.ie

Denis O'Leary granted Supreme Court appeal over expert fees in Mercy Hospital case

By Rory Hanlon

Historic decision · Decision date:

The Supreme Court refused leave on the negligence findings but will hear his claim about fair procedures and fees paid to two medical experts.

The Supreme Court granted Denis O'Leary leave to appeal on 27 July 2018, but on one ground only. He sued Mercy University Hospital Cork Limited and Khalid M Ali Chiad Al-Safi.

Mr O'Leary brought a medical negligence action over an operation he underwent. The High Court found against him on negligence and on informed consent. Before his appeal, he asked to put additional evidence before the Court of Appeal.

That evidence concerned fees paid to two medical consultants retained by the defendants. Mr O'Leary said one was paid €27,230 and the other €19,870. He said the fees came to light only on taxation of costs. The defendants said the fees were in line with those charged by experts for plaintiffs in such cases.

The Court of Appeal ruled on 12 March 2018, and Mr O'Leary applied to the Supreme Court on 16 April 2018. He claimed breaches of Article 40.3 of the Constitution and Articles 6.1 and 13 of the European Convention on Human Rights. He argued the fees could give rise to a perception of bias.

The Supreme Court refused leave on the negligence and consent issues. It found no error and no matter of general public importance. It granted leave on the claims about fair procedures and trial in due course of law, which it said arguably raise questions of general public importance.

The Court said an issue may arise over whether these questions are better dealt with in plenary proceedings in the High Court. It will address that and other matters in case management.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal