The Supreme Court granted Charles Chawke and Edward Bohan leave to appeal on 10 July 2018. They are defendants in proceedings brought by W.L. Construction Limited. It will hear their appeal against a Court of Appeal judgment of 26 April 2018.
The case turns on a so-called "Moorview" order. Such an order can make someone pay the costs of a case even though they are not a party to it. In this case the High Court made one against a third defendant, Mr Loughnane.
The Court of Appeal took the view that the order could not be made here. It said Mr Loughnane was not on notice that such an order might be sought when the case was before the High Court. Mr Chawke and Mr Bohan want that decision reviewed.
The Supreme Court said the issue is of general public importance. It said the extent of the court's power to make these orders has never been decided definitively by that court. The question could arise whenever someone funds litigation by a company with limited means, hoping to benefit if it succeeds. Without such an order, that person would not face the costs if the case failed.
Mr Loughnane opposed leave to appeal. The Court also granted him leave to cross appeal. He can ask whether, if the appeal succeeds, any order should cover only part of the costs. The Court said that question would not qualify on its own, but the interests of justice allowed it to be raised.
A case management judge will decide the precise grounds of appeal.