The Supreme Court granted David Mahon leave to appeal on 10 July 2018 over the sentence he received for manslaughter. It will hear an appeal against the Court of Appeal judgment of 7 December 2017.
Dean Fitzpatrick, Mr Mahon's step-son, died on 26 May 2013 from a deep knife wound. Mr Mahon presented himself at Coolock Garda Station the next morning. He was later charged with murder, and before the trial he offered a guilty plea to manslaughter. That offer was not accepted.
The jury returned a verdict of manslaughter. On 13 June 2016 Heneghan J sentenced Mr Mahon to seven years in prison. The Court of Appeal (Peart, Birmingham and Mahon JJ) refused his sentence appeal on 7 December 2017. He applied to the Supreme Court on 7 February 2018.
Mr Mahon argued that the Court of Appeal wrongly accepted how the sentencing judge dealt with the facts. He said unclear facts should have been taken in the way most favourable to him. The Director of Public Prosecutions opposed leave. She said the law on sentencing in such cases had not changed. She also said he was serving a suspended sentence on the night, did not call for medical help and disposed of the weapon.
The Supreme Court said the matter requires clarification and raises issues of general public importance. It identified three questions for the appeal, subject to case management.
The first is what facts a trial judge may rely on when sentencing for manslaughter after a jury has acquitted of murder. The second is how a judge sets a sentence for a crime where the facts vary so widely. The third is whether the trial judge took the right approach in this case and whether the sentence was appropriate.