The Supreme Court refused Helena Merriman and 21 other residents leave to appeal on 6 July 2018. They had asked to appeal directly from the High Court. Their case was against Fingal County Council, Ireland and the Attorney General, with Dublin Airport Authority PLC and Ryanair DAC as notice parties.
The residents challenged the council's decision to extend the time to build a runway at Dublin Airport. The permission was granted on 29 August 2007 for ten years. The extension, applied for on 11 January 2017, runs for five years to 28 August 2022.
The High Court rejected their challenge in a judgment of 21 November 2017. It held that the extension was not a development consent under the EIA Directive. It also held that the law did not require public consultation. On 14 February 2018 it refused them a certificate to appeal to the Court of Appeal.
The Supreme Court said the High Court had applied settled case law, so no matter of general public importance arose. It said the Habitats Directive point rested on a bare assertion with no evidence. It also refused to make a reference to the European Court of Justice.
The application was out of time and the Court found the explanation inadequate. It would have refused the extension of time, but considered the substance anyway.
The Court stressed that its refusal does not decide the other points in the High Court judgment.