localnews.ie

Catherine Nevin granted Supreme Court appeal over use of murder conviction in estate case

By Tadhg O'Sullivan

Historic decision · Decision date:

The court will decide whether her conviction for murdering Thomas Nevin at Jack White's Inn, Brittas Bay, can be used against her in a civil claim.

The Supreme Court will hear an appeal by Catherine Nevin in the civil case over the estate of her late husband, Thomas Nevin. It granted her leave on 31 July 2017.

She is appealing a Court of Appeal decision of 7 March 2017 (Finlay Geoghegan J., Irvine J., Hedigan J.). That court dismissed her appeal against a High Court ruling by Kearns P. on 1 March 2013.

Thomas Nevin was murdered on 19 March 1996 at his licensed premises, Jack White's, in Brittas Bay, County Wicklow. The couple jointly owned the inn. Catherine Nevin reopened it and ran it until it was sold in 1997 for Ir£620,000. She was convicted of murder and other charges, including soliciting his murder, and given a life sentence by the Central Criminal Court. She has always denied any involvement in his death.

The civil case began on 4 November 1997, brought by Thomas Nevin's mother, Nora Nevin. She sought declarations that Catherine Nevin should not take any share of his estate or the inn. Nora Nevin died in 1999. Her son Patrick Nevin and daughter Margaret Lavelle were joined as plaintiffs in 2001. The case lay on hold during the criminal proceedings.

The plaintiffs asked the High Court to decide first whether her murder conviction was admissible as evidence. Kearns P. held it was admissible as prima facie evidence that she committed the murder, and the Court of Appeal upheld that.

Ms Nevin says the Court of Appeal wrongly extended the exception to the rule against hearsay. The plaintiffs say the ruling rested on the common law and the law of evidence. The Supreme Court said the issue is far from simple and the law and procedure need clarification. It will decide whether the plaintiffs' pre-emptive motion was appropriate, whether the Court of Appeal was correct, whether a challenge to the conviction would be an abuse of process, and whether Hollington v Hewthorn remains good law in Ireland.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal