Paul Gannon has been granted leave to appeal to the Supreme Court over his arrest for drink driving. The court gave its decision on 31 July 2017.
The arrest took place on the hard shoulder of the M50, which the garda said was very busy. The arresting garda told the District Court that, having formed the opinion Mr Gannon was intoxicated, he handcuffed him for his own safety, for the safety of gardaí and for other road users. It was accepted that Mr Gannon was compliant and not aggressive.
District Judge Bryan Smith held that the handcuffing was not justified and dismissed the basis of the arrest. At the prosecution's request he put the question to the High Court, where Barrett J. ruled on 9 July 2015 that the District judge was wrong in law.
The Court of Appeal (Sheehan J., Mahon J., Edwards J.) dismissed Mr Gannon's appeal on 21 December 2016. It held that the test for handcuffing is primarily subjective, based on the arresting garda's genuine assessment. The Director of Public Prosecutions, at the suit of Garda David Kenny, opposed leave.
Mr Gannon says that ruling is wrong and that the High Court and Court of Appeal went behind the District judge's findings of fact. He also contends there are apparently conflicting dicta in earlier judgments, and that prosecutions are waiting on a final decision.
The Supreme Court said two issues of general public importance arise. It will decide whether the lower courts correctly applied the law on appeals by way of case stated, and whether they correctly applied the Supreme Court's own decision in DPP v Cullen.