James Corrigan has been granted leave to appeal to the Supreme Court over the use of handcuffs when he was arrested on a drink-driving charge. The court gave its decision on 31 July 2017.
Mr Corrigan applied to appeal from a Court of Appeal judgment delivered on 21 December 2016. The other party is the Director of Public Prosecutions, at the suit of Garda David Kenny. The Court of Appeal dealt with his case in the same judgment as those of Cicero Pires and Paul Gannon, which raise the same issues.
The arresting garda said Mr Corrigan was "jittery" and hesitated when the garda put a hand on him to guide him to the patrol car. The man was not aggressive and was co-operative. The garda said he feared Mr Corrigan might panic, that the arrest was on a busy dual carriageway, and that the patrol car had no internal protective barrier.
District Judge Bryan Smith held the handcuffing was not justified and dismissed the basis of the arrest. The High Court (Barrett J.) held that this was wrong in law. The Court of Appeal (Sheehan J., Mahon J., Edwards J.) upheld that decision and found that the test for using handcuffs is primarily subjective, not one of objective reasonableness.
Mr Corrigan argues that the Court of Appeal wrongly looked behind the District judge's findings of fact when deciding whether a point of law arose. He also argues the test for handcuffing should be objective reasonableness. The Director says the law was settled in DPP v Cullen and was correctly applied.
The Supreme Court found two issues of general public importance. The first is whether the High Court and Court of Appeal applied the rules on appeals by way of case stated correctly. The second is whether they applied Cullen correctly.