The Supreme Court will hear an appeal by Cicero Pires over the use of handcuffs when gardaí arrested him on suspicion of drink driving. It granted him leave to appeal from the Court of Appeal on 31 July 2017.
The Director of Public Prosecutions, at the suit of Garda David Kenny, is the other party. The Court of Appeal dealt with his case in the same judgment as two others, those of James Corrigan and Paul Gannon, which raise the same issues. Mr Pires was stopped on suspicion of driving under the influence of alcohol and was handcuffed during his arrest. The garda told the District Court he did so because Mr Pires was intoxicated, larger in stature, and because he was alone with him and had to bring him in a garda vehicle with no internal protective barrier.
District Judge Bryan Smith held that the handcuffing was not justified as a precaution and dismissed the basis of the arrest. At the prosecution's request he asked the High Court whether he was correct in law to find the arrest unlawful. Barrett J. said he was not, in a judgment of 9 July 2015.
The Court of Appeal (Sheehan J., Mahon J., Edwards J.) dismissed the appeals on 21 December 2016. It held that the test for using handcuffs is primarily subjective, turning on the arresting garda's genuine assessment of what the situation required.
Mr Pires says the High Court and Court of Appeal went behind the District judge's findings of fact. He also says the test should be objective reasonableness. The Director said the law was already settled in an earlier Supreme Court case, DPP v Cullen.
The Supreme Court said two issues of general public importance arise. They are whether the lower courts correctly applied the rules on appeals by way of case stated, and whether they correctly applied Cullen.