The Supreme Court refused Finbar Tolan leave to appeal on 28 July 2017 in his case with Kiernan Milling. Mr Tolan had applied to appeal from the Court of Appeal.
He lodged two applications, covering two orders of Hanna J. in the High Court. One, made on 17 September 2014, found there had been no express agreement between the parties to settle the proceedings for €19,000. The other, made on 26 June 2015, awarded the plaintiff €44,892.50. The Court of Appeal dealt with the case on 14 November 2016.
Mr Tolan complained about access to the DAR from the High Court before the appeal hearing. He said the plaintiff company had not properly proved its contract with him. He also said Ryan P. should not have sat on the appeal because of earlier dealings with the case in the High Court. Mr Milling said Ryan P. did not hear the High Court proceedings and that the court orders record Hanna J.
The Supreme Court said it was impossible to work out what the case was about or why Mr Tolan should have leave. It said the registrar wrote to him in January 2017 pointing out that his papers were inadequate and not in line with the rules.
The court found he had not made out grounds meeting the constitutional criteria for a second appeal, which are general public importance or the interests of justice. Leave to appeal was refused.