The Supreme Court will hear an appeal by An Taisce against the High Court's refusal to restrain quarrying by McTigue Quarries Limited, Garry McTigue and Caroline McTigue. It granted An Taisce leave to appeal directly from the High Court in a determination delivered on 28 July 2017.
An Taisce had asked the High Court for an order under section 160 of the Planning and Development Act 2000 to stop the quarrying. It argued that a substitute consent, a form of permission introduced after a finding by the Court of Justice of the European Union, could not authorise continuing quarrying without an environmental impact assessment.
In a judgment delivered on 8 November 2016, Mr Justice Barrett found that McTigue Quarries was carrying on unauthorised development. He nonetheless used the discretion he has under section 160 not to make the order.
The respondents did not oppose leave but said they would contest the appeal on its merits. The Supreme Court noted that it must still satisfy itself that the constitutional test is met.
It found a matter of general public importance. The substitute consent regime could apply beyond this case, and it arises from European Union obligations that Ireland has been found to have breached. The court added that the criteria for the section 160 discretion, where a breach of law required by European law is alleged, were a further point of public importance.
It also found exceptional circumstances for a direct appeal. The matter was urgent, and the court said the issues, though important and complex, would gain little from an intermediate appeal to the Court of Appeal.
The appeal will decide whether it was open to the High Court to decline an order under section 160 despite finding unauthorised development. The McTigue respondents may argue that no unauthorised development occurred, and they do not need separate leave to do so.