localnews.ie

Supreme Court to hear SPV Osus appeal against HSBC over assigned legal claim

By Tadhg O'Sullivan

Historic decision · Decision date:

The company, which relies on an assignment made in New York bankruptcy proceedings, was granted leave after the court held its argument was fairly before the Court of Appeal.

The Supreme Court will hear an appeal by SPV Osus Limited in its case against HSBC Institutional Trust Services (Ireland) Limited and others. It granted the company leave to appeal in a determination delivered on 25 July 2017.

Osus is suing HSBC Institutional Trust Services (Ireland) Limited, HSBC Securities Services (Ireland) Limited, Optimal Investment Services S.A. and Banco Santander S.A. It says an assignment made in bankruptcy proceedings in New York gives it a legal right to bring the claims in the Irish courts.

The High Court, in a judgment of Mr Justice Costello on 5 October 2015, concluded that the assignment would not be recognised in Irish law. The Court of Appeal, in a judgment delivered by its President, Mr Justice Ryan, on 2 March 2017, dismissed Osus's appeal.

HSBC opposed leave. It said Osus was raising points that had not been argued in the High Court or the Court of Appeal. The Supreme Court held an oral hearing on that question.

The court said litigants must keep in mind that "a trial is not a rehearsal". It said it would set its face against parties inventing new grounds just to meet the test for a further appeal.

It found, however, that the central question had been fairly before the Court of Appeal. Any change in how Osus now puts its argument was, in the court's view, an evolution or refinement of the case it made there.

The court also found a matter of general public importance. It said there has been no recent definitive ruling on where the line lies in Irish law between assignments of a cause of action that are recognised and those that are not.

Leave was granted on two issues. The first is when an assignment of a cause of action is valid in Irish law. The second is whether the Court of Appeal was right to refuse to recognise the assignment Osus relies on.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal