localnews.ie

Seán Guerin granted Supreme Court appeal in Alan Shatter case over Garda review report

By Ruairí Dolan

Historic decision · Decision date:

Mr Guerin, who carried out the review of allegations by Sergeant Maurice McCabe, was granted leave on three issues after the court heard oral submissions on 28 June 2017.

The Supreme Court will hear an appeal by Seán Guerin in the legal action brought against him by Alan Shatter. It granted Mr Guerin leave to appeal in a determination delivered on 21 July 2017.

The case arises from the review Mr Guerin carried out after the Government announced in 2014 that it would examine allegations made by Sergeant Maurice McCabe about Garda misconduct. Mr Shatter was Minister for Justice at the time. Mr Guerin delivered his report to the Taoiseach on 6 May 2014, and Mr Shatter resigned his government position the next day.

Mr Shatter complained about statements in chapters 19 and 20 of the report, which he said contained seven conclusions adverse to his interests. He sought judicial review against Mr Guerin. The High Court dismissed his application on 20 May 2015, finding the matter arose from political decisions of the Government that the court should not adjudicate on.

Mr Shatter appealed. On 10 November 2016, the Court of Appeal upheld his appeal. It declared that the conclusions in the report breached fair procedures and constitutional and natural justice.

Mr Guerin then sought leave to appeal to the Supreme Court. Mr Shatter opposed the application, arguing that it concerned Mr Guerin's own rights only and was governed by its own unique facts.

The Supreme Court heard oral submissions from counsel on 28 June 2017. It then found the application met the constitutional test of general public importance.

Leave was granted on three issues. They are whether Mr Shatter's claim was justiciable when it was started; how far fair procedures and constitutional justice apply to a task of this kind, and whether the judicial review was a collateral attack on the decision to set up a Commission of Investigation; and whether the duty of full disclosure when seeking judicial review still applies, and if so whether it was breached by the allegation of bias against Mr Guerin.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal