localnews.ie

Ryanair refused Supreme Court appeal in internet defamation case against Peter John Fleming

By Tadhg O'Sullivan

Historic decision · Decision date:

The Supreme Court said the airline had not identified a point of law of general public importance in its bid to serve defamation proceedings on a pilot in Australia.

Ryanair Limited has been refused leave to appeal to the Supreme Court in its defamation case against Peter John Fleming. The Supreme Court delivered its determination on 23 January 2017.

Ryanair claims it was defamed by comments Mr Fleming posted on an internet chat forum about incidents involving its aircraft. Mr Fleming is an airline pilot who lives in Australia and has never been to Ireland. The High Court (O'Connor J.) set aside an order permitting service on him outside the jurisdiction, and the Court of Appeal affirmed that.

The Court of Appeal found there was uncontradicted evidence that an Irish judgment would not be enforced in Australia. It gave two main reasons. There was no evidence that the post had been accessed or downloaded in Ireland, and even if it had, the connection between the alleged wrong and this jurisdiction was too tenuous for Ireland to be the natural forum.

Ryanair argued that the law on service out of the jurisdiction and on proving internet defamation needed clarifying.

The Supreme Court said whether publication was proved in Ireland is a fact-specific matter that it would not review. It noted that Ryanair had not addressed the principle that a foreign defendant should normally be sued where he lives, and that the case was governed entirely by national law. Leave was refused.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal