localnews.ie

Angela Kerins granted Supreme Court appeal over Public Accounts Committee hearing

By Orla Quinn

Historic decision · Decision date:

The Supreme Court will hear her case directly from the High Court, along with two related costs appeals, on the legal safeguards for witnesses who appear before the committee.

Angela Kerins has been granted leave to appeal directly to the Supreme Court in her case against members of the Dáil Public Accounts Committee (PAC). The decision was delivered on 10 July 2017.

A Divisional Court of the High Court (Kelly P., Noonan and Kennedy JJ.) had dismissed her claim. It arose from PAC proceedings on 27 February and 10 April 2014. She had sought injunctive and declaratory reliefs and damages by way of judicial review.

Ms Kerins said she attended voluntarily and was questioned for about seven hours. She said she was asked about many matters she had not been told about. She said the questioning damaged her personally and professionally.

She argued that the Divisional Court had in effect reversed earlier Supreme Court decisions, In Re Haughey and Maguire v. Ardagh. She said the case raised freedom of speech in Parliament, the separation of powers and how far the courts may interfere in the affairs of the Legislature.

The PAC respondents and the State respondents did not oppose a direct appeal. The State disputed that the Divisional Court had departed from the earlier decisions.

The Supreme Court said that did not change its duty to apply the constitutional test. It found the case raises a matter of general public importance. That is the legal safeguards for voluntary witnesses before PAC, and what role the courts have in protecting them.

It also found the interests of justice were engaged. The Divisional Court had found Ms Kerins was damaged professionally and personally but had no legal remedy.

A direct appeal needs exceptional circumstances. The Court found them here, because an early resolution of the constitutional issues outweighed the benefit of an intermediate appeal.

The Court also granted leave on two costs issues. The PAC respondents challenge the order giving Ms Kerins two thirds of her High Court costs. The State challenges the order that made no order for costs in its favour. All three applications will be case managed.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal