Aqua Fresh Fish Limited has been granted leave by the Supreme Court to appeal over whether its managing director should be allowed to represent the company in court proceedings.
The determination, [2017] IESCDET 76, says the company sought leave to appeal from a Court of Appeal decision. The Supreme Court granted leave on whether the rule in Battle v Irish Art Promotion Centre Ltd should apply in every case where a company director seeks to represent the company, and, if not, what criteria should govern permission.
The underlying proceedings were brought by Allied Irish Banks, which seeks possession and, if necessary, the sale of property mortgaged by the company. The bank’s claim is based on an alleged loan payment default. The determination says Adrian Flynn, the company’s managing director and, he says, its 100% owner, argued that it lacked funds for legal representation and that he should be permitted to represent it as an exception to the established rule.
The Court of Appeal had found that the case did not fall within the rare and exceptional category that could justify departing from that rule, and that it was bound by the earlier decision. The High Court had also expressed the view that the company’s proposed defence did not appear to be a real, arguable defence with a reasonable chance of success; the determination records that the defence’s merits had not been fully examined.
The Supreme Court said the company had raised a point of general public importance. It clarified that granting leave decides only whether the constitutional criteria for an appeal are met; the legal question will be determined in the substantive appeal. The Court recommended that the company contact the Registrar about a scheme for free legal representation for the appeal, given the complexity of the arguments that may arise.