localnews.ie

Killross Properties granted Supreme Court cross-appeal in ESB land access dispute

By Donal Gilhooly

Historic decision · Decision date:

The cross-appeal will examine whether an infrastructure agreement with EirGrid and the companies' licences stopped the ESB using its section 53 powers to seek entry to land.

The Supreme Court has granted Killross Properties Limited leave to bring a cross-appeal in its dispute with the Electricity Supply Board and EirGrid plc. The determination was delivered on 19 June 2017.

The application follows a separate determination issued the same day, which granted the ESB leave to appeal the one point on which Killross won in the Court of Appeal. Killross lost most of its other grounds, and it now seeks to appeal some of those.

Killross argued that its point raises an issue beyond the facts of this case. It described that issue as covering the entire machinery by which electricity transmission powers and functions have been assigned under the Irish unbundling regulatory regime.

The ESB said the only real issue on this heading, in both the High Court and the Court of Appeal, was whether an official, Mr Waldron, signed and served the entry notice on its behalf.

The Supreme Court was not convinced that Killross's issue is necessarily one of general public importance. It said it did not need to decide that point.

It granted leave in the interests of justice. An appeal will go before the Supreme Court in any event because the ESB has been given leave, and the court said it would not be in the interests of justice to confine that appeal to the point Killross won.

The court stressed the limits of its decision. A respondent whose opponent has been given leave is not automatically entitled to pursue a cross-appeal, and it said "each case must be considered on its own merits".

The cross-appeal will ask whether the ESB was precluded from using its power under section 53 of the Electricity (Supply) Act 1927 because of an infrastructure agreement with EirGrid and the licences granted to both companies. The precise grounds may be refined at the first case management hearing.

It will be case managed with the ESB's appeal, and both parties must file one set of submissions covering both.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal